All Ospreys discussion here please!
Moderators: Tigerbeat, Rizzo, Tigers Press Office, Tigers Webmaster
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
first of all hello to you all , and i must say on the whole i have been very impressed by the way your supporters generally viewed the game and the cock up over 16th man.
But a couple of points must be noted first off byrne has appealled as his is right, or does anyone else not remember martin johnson appealling against one of his bans for punching he appealed at last minute , hearing was held for following week after the match that he was banned for, so he could play . strangely enough it was wales at twickers if i remember correctly. another sportsman using the system. he had no grounds for appeal as he admitted that he walloped a saracens player for no reason, yet he was needed for that english match so much.
Also to me the persons at fault here are the officials AND/OR the ospreys as no one seems to know both sides of the story. its quite clear that the ospreys touch line lady had talked to 4th official who seemed to be struck dumb at the time lewis was berating the lady in front of the cameras.
also lewis after game had restarted still had trouble understanding or hearing his officials properly when he was told of substituion involving taking Biggar off.
Also why hasn`t lewis been taken to task over his failure to enforce rules. if he had this matter would have been sorted without any bans or fines. The fines have only come about due to wheeler making such a commotion about a simple mistake, and poor reffing. after all there is no guarantee leicester would have kicked the penalty, which would have still kept them behind by 2 points, and they did not score again.
from my personal view i want Byrne to play as he`s a very good player, and allthough england have not played well lately, we have`nt had an easy game at twickenham since the 70`s , and this game could go either way.
But lets hope saturday is remembered for quality rugby not controversy.
But a couple of points must be noted first off byrne has appealled as his is right, or does anyone else not remember martin johnson appealling against one of his bans for punching he appealed at last minute , hearing was held for following week after the match that he was banned for, so he could play . strangely enough it was wales at twickers if i remember correctly. another sportsman using the system. he had no grounds for appeal as he admitted that he walloped a saracens player for no reason, yet he was needed for that english match so much.
Also to me the persons at fault here are the officials AND/OR the ospreys as no one seems to know both sides of the story. its quite clear that the ospreys touch line lady had talked to 4th official who seemed to be struck dumb at the time lewis was berating the lady in front of the cameras.
also lewis after game had restarted still had trouble understanding or hearing his officials properly when he was told of substituion involving taking Biggar off.
Also why hasn`t lewis been taken to task over his failure to enforce rules. if he had this matter would have been sorted without any bans or fines. The fines have only come about due to wheeler making such a commotion about a simple mistake, and poor reffing. after all there is no guarantee leicester would have kicked the penalty, which would have still kept them behind by 2 points, and they did not score again.
from my personal view i want Byrne to play as he`s a very good player, and allthough england have not played well lately, we have`nt had an easy game at twickenham since the 70`s , and this game could go either way.
But lets hope saturday is remembered for quality rugby not controversy.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Sun Dec 25, 2005 5:08 pm
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Lee Byrne has been cleared to play for WALES , they've given him a 5,000 euro fine instead. :)
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
So basically Ospreys get away with it.
Yeah it's a fine but why not ban him with a ban to start AFTER the 6 Nations? Is it that hard?
Anyway lets draw a line under it.
Yeah it's a fine but why not ban him with a ban to start AFTER the 6 Nations? Is it that hard?
Anyway lets draw a line under it.
Richard Burnett
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
it's here ..TTRITH wrote:Anyway lets draw a line under it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
- Super User
- Posts: 14868
- Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 6:23 pm
- Location: Essex
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Two weeks = 5000 euros.
So 70 weeks = 175000 euros.
23 weeks = 57500 euros
Would Max pay that for Attoub and Dupuy?
Likely.
So 70 weeks = 175000 euros.
23 weeks = 57500 euros
Would Max pay that for Attoub and Dupuy?
Likely.
Still keeping the faith!
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Can it be a thicker line so you don't meet us in the first and last match of next years HC?Tircoeds wrote:it's here ..TTRITH wrote:Anyway lets draw a line under it.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I love the annual trip to the Liberty, it's just a bit too far!
Richard Burnett
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 12063
- Joined: Tue Feb 08, 2005 1:54 pm
- Location: Somewhere down the crazy river
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
TTRITH wrote:
Anyway lets draw a line under it.
Couldn't agree more. It is what it is, move on.
Don't waste your time away thinking about yesterday's blues
Demelza - another Mother
Demelza - another Mother
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
so WRU who instigated the appeal pay the fine. So who loses no one except those hard done by
-
- Super User
- Posts: 14868
- Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 6:23 pm
- Location: Essex
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
I would love to believe that we can.Rizzo wrote:Couldn't agree more. It is what it is, move on.
But I don't.
The whole "debacle" (Rizzo's word) is just yet another example of madadminstration and incompetence by ERC who show no remorse or even recognition of their failures.
Still keeping the faith!
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Just hope future games between our teams can pass without the incidents that seems to now plague these fixtures.
Enough with the dramas.
Good luck in the prem tigers.
Enough with the dramas.
Good luck in the prem tigers.
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Want to see the true villain on the piece...........
http://forum.gwladrugby.com/attachment. ... 1265147464
http://forum.gwladrugby.com/attachment. ... 1265147464
Ospreys....Top Flight Rugby
-
- Super User
- Posts: 14868
- Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2009 6:23 pm
- Location: Essex
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
It's got the wrong number in the shirt! Should be 16.RJW wrote:Want to see the true villain on the piece...........
http://forum.gwladrugby.com/attachment. ... 1265147464
Still keeping the faith!
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
I fear the ERC have failed yet again to show that they can run this competition. Try this thought exercise ;
2010 European cup final, 5 mins, to go. team A are on 30 points, team B 26 points. Team B are all out attacking team A's try line. What is there to stop team A fielding a 16th man?
Answer: not a lot.
I'm not trying to fan the flames (I think the 2 week ban was a bit harsh ) but clearly there is something wrong with the sanctions and the complete failure to deal with the officials.
Perhaps (if the ref knows what he's doing) it should be a penalty plus an amount of time added on to be played by 14 players by the offending side.
2010 European cup final, 5 mins, to go. team A are on 30 points, team B 26 points. Team B are all out attacking team A's try line. What is there to stop team A fielding a 16th man?
Answer: not a lot.
I'm not trying to fan the flames (I think the 2 week ban was a bit harsh ) but clearly there is something wrong with the sanctions and the complete failure to deal with the officials.
Perhaps (if the ref knows what he's doing) it should be a penalty plus an amount of time added on to be played by 14 players by the offending side.
find a better way of life, http://www.marillion.com
marillion 19, coming ....er not sure..
marillion 19, coming ....er not sure..
Re: All Ospreys discussion here please!
Because despite your management and lawyers best efforts, the result of the initial hearing was found to be incorrect (their words not mine).TTRITH wrote:So basically Ospreys get away with it.
Yeah it's a fine but why not ban him with a ban to start AFTER the 6 Nations? Is it that hard?
Anyway lets draw a line under it.
You will also be pleased to hear that your high powered lawyers were asked to demonstrate why this was different to the 2003 RWC episode and failed badly.