mol2 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 06, 2021 11:00 pm
If the water carriers were not permitted to enter without permission then the issue of getting in the line of kickers would not occur.
Water carriers should not be on the pitch when kicks are being taken. There have been instances where an injured player has been attended to in line of the kicker and the ref has given the kicker the option to take the kick or wait, stopping the clock.
Only when the clock has been stopped are non-medic water carriers supposed to be on the pitch.
I agree water carriers are permitted on to the field of play.
I agree it was an over reaction by 36.
I do not agree with personnel interfering directly with the game. The water"boy" did lean over and touch the ball dead.
What resulted was farcical. 36 gets penalised for his overreaction. (Granted).
The Waterboy gets sent to the stands away from the game. Presumably so he cannot interfere further.
Result Glaws are penalised twice. Once by ref and by the actions of water"boy". The water"boy" has a natural replacement.
Some how does not sit right.
wellstiger wrote: ↑Thu Jan 07, 2021 10:50 am
I agree water carriers are permitted on to the field of play.
I agree it was an over reaction by 36.
I do not agree with personnel interfering directly with the game. The water"boy" did lean over and touch the ball dead.
What resulted was farcical. 36 gets penalised for his overreaction. (Granted).
The Waterboy gets sent to the stands away from the game. Presumably so he cannot interfere further.
Result Glaws are penalised twice. Once by ref and by the actions of water"boy". The water"boy" has a natural replacement.
Some how does not sit right.
It doesn't sit right because the message is "tell your water carriers to interfere with play and you will benefit from it". I'm sure we'll see it much more often now, water carriers and other non playing staff grabbing the ball to try to wind up opposition players and win a penalty and yellow card. Hopefully next time it happens it will be dealt with properly and the correct message will be sent.
Any ancillary person interfering with the game should be removed from the ground and banned for at least 4 games. the offending side should also have their captain yellow carded and a penalty awarded against them. This sort of interference is no different to having an extra player on the pitch and needs to be stopped now.