Search found 327 matches
- Wed Feb 17, 2021 11:28 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sort the tackle area out, please!
- Replies: 97
- Views: 5579
Re: Sort the tackle area out, please!
If the laws were applied there is no need to clear out the jackaller, just touching him renders him in an illegal position 'Contact' is not just touching, it is interpreted as binding, so just touching the jackaller does not form a ruck. Your point about binding is for players joining the ruck not ...
- Tue Feb 16, 2021 12:23 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sort the tackle area out, please!
- Replies: 97
- Views: 5579
Re: Sort the tackle area out, please!
How does latching/pods work with the laws? Nothing illegal about latching, the refs are asking that latching happens only after the ball is in the possession of the player at the front, this is just for safety and the prevent obstruction. That is to say these pick and drives, where one or more play...
- Tue Feb 16, 2021 11:05 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sort the tackle area out, please!
- Replies: 97
- Views: 5579
Re: Sort the tackle area out, please!
" The purpose of a ruck is to allow players to compete for the ball which is on the ground " from the laws of rugby. A Jackal can only take place before a ruck is formed, i.e at the tackle after the tackler has released the tackled player and the tackled player has the opportunity to place...
- Thu Feb 11, 2021 11:46 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sort the tackle area out, please!
- Replies: 97
- Views: 5579
Re: Sort the tackle area out, please!
The scrums are a farce not because they can't compete, but because the front rows decide not to and mostly conspire to cheat, supported by weak refs such as Pearce, CM-K, Carley, Dickson none of which can ref a scrum properly. That kind of encapsulates the situation. Front rows to manipulate their ...
- Thu Feb 11, 2021 11:42 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sort the tackle area out, please!
- Replies: 97
- Views: 5579
Re: Sort the tackle area out, please!
"Remove substitutes except for genuine injury and keep the game speed up then these 20 stone behemoths would soon be slimming down. John Pullin was 15 stone and a first rate hooker." This I agree with, substitutions should be for genuine injuries only, verified by a doctor and any player s...
- Sun Feb 07, 2021 8:45 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: 6 NATIONS 2021
- Replies: 1546
- Views: 72210
Re: 6 NATIONS 2021
Young's being subbed summed up the EJ approach, it is all pre-programmed, EJ is mentally rigid and the team is tactical rigid as a result, if the coach cannot adapt to circumstances how can the team do so?
Young's was not the problem and his replacement was not the solution!
Young's was not the problem and his replacement was not the solution!
- Sun Feb 07, 2021 8:31 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Tigers vs Worcester - Sat 06 Feb 1500
- Replies: 421
- Views: 22775
Re: Tigers vs Worcester - Sat 06 Feb 1500
Very happy with the win but a team sheet with so many SA and Argentinian exiles gives me mixed feelings, I see the reasoning but I just do not like it, sorry.
- Thu Feb 04, 2021 12:03 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Advantage Law - Just let them score!
- Replies: 14
- Views: 987
Re: Advantage Law - Just let them score!
Another one where people look through the wrong end of the telescope IMHO, if the attacking team has an advantage close to the line and the defending team offend again, by creeping offside or hands in the ruck, the ref should just blow up for a penalty try, not just keep playing until someone gets c...
- Sun Jan 31, 2021 1:47 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Sale game moved - Teams up
- Replies: 354
- Views: 23498
Re: Sale game moved - Teams up
Having re-watched both Tigers v Sale and Bears v Bath, there are some striking things to see, while seeing Bath humiliated was a joy, the comparison of Bears v Tigers was not so uplifting, I know the Bears have taken time to get this good but the intention has been there from the off, their relentle...
- Fri Jan 15, 2021 10:11 am
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Gallagher Premiership Round 6
- Replies: 129
- Views: 13081
Re: Gallagher Premiership Round 6
The citing of Sinckler totally undermines the ref, he heard the comment and dealt with it, what is the point in having a hearing, leave the refs to deal with it, if they do not see it or make a clear error OK but you must allow refs to remain in charge! For me he should have got a yellow card, no w...
- Tue Jan 12, 2021 5:49 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Gallagher Premiership Round 6
- Replies: 129
- Views: 13081
Re: Gallagher Premiership Round 6
The citing of Sinckler totally undermines the ref, he heard the comment and dealt with it, what is the point in having a hearing, leave the refs to deal with it, if they do not see it or make a clear error OK but you must allow refs to remain in charge! For me he should have got a yellow card, no wa...
- Fri Jan 08, 2021 12:24 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Round 5 other fixtures
- Replies: 103
- Views: 6500
Re: Round 5 other fixtures
It is a strange world, we have an offence that actually causes harm (player taken off for HIA) and an offence that does not, which gets 3 weeks and which gets 4?
The TMO should be banned for life if that is the best he can do!
The TMO should be banned for life if that is the best he can do!
- Mon Jan 04, 2021 4:20 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Non playing staff interfering with play
- Replies: 51
- Views: 4636
Re: Non playing staff interfering with play
The water carrier was in the technical area behind his barrier and the ball was coming towards him. Instinct to get the ball or sinister, Twelvetrees was an idiot in how he reacted. The water carrier was in his specified area. Strange how we remember things to suit or perceptions but I though the w...
- Sun Jan 03, 2021 10:35 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Use it
- Replies: 24
- Views: 2026
Re: Use it
If the ref has called “use it” a secondary shove should not occur. The scum is effectively over. That depends on the interpretation of the term, use it, IMHO the scrum marching forward is a valid use of a rugby ball, so once the scrum and ball started towards the try line the refs instruction had b...
- Wed Dec 30, 2020 5:11 pm
- Forum: Fans Forum
- Topic: Exeter overhyped?
- Replies: 44
- Views: 4021
Re: Exeter overhyped?
the only premiership team to have been profitable in the last two full years This is where I get a little wary, assuming Exeter spend up to the cap, and have a gate of 50% less than of Tigers, how can they possibly produce a profit unless they charge double what Tigers charge? I know this is being ...